Skip to content

Maybe you know this moment. It is evening, the flat is quiet, and suddenly there is a pull that drowns out everything else. It comes as a tug through your whole body: restlessness in the chest, a tight throat, a hand already reaching for the phone. Your arguments are still there somewhere, but they sound faint and far away. What is left is the feeling that something is about to be decided for you and that all you can do is watch. The word for it is craving. It can turn up with alcohol, nicotine, gambling, media or some other pattern. This article starts from a sentence that keeps coming back in Anker: an urge is not a decision. It explains why that sentence can be true even when it does not feel that way in the moment, and what you can do beforehand so that a little space opens up between urge and action.

Why an urge feels like a decision

A strong urge feels urgent. The body reports tension, your attention narrows, and the future shrinks to the next few minutes. In that narrow space, every sentence that leads back to the habit sounds reasonable: “Just this once.” “I will stop afterwards.” “Today does not matter anyway.” If you hear sentences like these in your head, you have nothing to reproach yourself for. They come with the urge, just like the pull in the body.

The course of craving is often described like this: it rises, reaches a peak and eases off again, a bit like a wave. As a rule of thumb, people often say that the peak passes after a few minutes. That is a rule of thumb, not a guarantee. Some urges fade faster, others come back in waves, and how strong they are depends on sleep, stress, surroundings and much else. The picture is still useful, because it makes the question smaller. You do not have to work out how to get rid of craving for good. It is enough to ask how you get through the next few minutes.

In the relapse-prevention literature, high-risk situations play a central role, for example in the model by Marlatt and Gordon (1985). It describes how, in such a situation, it can make a difference whether a coping strategy is ready. If you have something you can do, you tend to feel capable of acting. If you have nothing to hand, you tend to feel at the mercy of the moment. That is a model, not a law of nature, but it fits what many people report.

This is what the sentence “an urge is not a decision” is getting at. An urge happens to you. A decision is something you make. Between the two there can be a gap, and it has little to do with character or staying power. It comes from what you prepared before things got loud.

Change the situation first, think afterwards

The obvious reflex is to argue with the urge: collect arguments, remind yourself of your reasons, picture the consequences. On a calm day that is valuable. At the peak it often hits a limit, because you are negotiating with the same mind that is being pulled by the urge, and the urge has more stamina than any argument. Many people report that it is easier to move the body than to move the thoughts.

That is why the SOS flow in Anker does not start with questions. The first page says: “Change your situation now.” Below it are five suggestions that do not ask for a decision: stand up, leave the room, put your phone away, go outside, splash cold water on your face. Each one changes something concrete: the place, what is within reach, the temperature on your skin. Many triggers are tied to places, devices or times of day, and if you change the place, you take at least part of the stage away from the urge. Some people describe that something loosens as soon as they stand up.

Whether this works for you, I cannot know. It is a step so small that it can succeed even when nothing else does. The questions come only afterwards, at a point when thinking is a little easier again.

Watching the wave, and naming it

The wave picture goes with an idea called urge surfing. It is usually associated with Marlatt. The point is neither to fight the urge nor to follow it, but to watch it for a while: where in the body does it sit, how does it change, does it grow stronger or weaker? In 2009 Bowen and Marlatt studied a brief mindfulness-based instruction of this kind with college students who smoked. That was one study with a particular group and a short intervention. It makes the idea interesting, but it does not show that it holds for you, for another pattern, or in a very intense moment. It is also not an exercise for the first second. Watching is easier once you are out of the situation and have a little distance.

A second idea is about language. In 2007 Lieberman and colleagues showed, in a laboratory study, that when people looked at faces with emotional expressions and put the feeling into words, a brain scan showed less activity in the amygdala than during other tasks. The amygdala is a brain region involved in processing strong emotional stimuli. It was an experiment with pictures, not craving in everyday life, and you cannot derive instructions for a real emergency from it. It does fit an experience many people describe: whatever can be named becomes a little easier to hold.

In Anker this appears twice. In SOS you give the pull a number and a place in the body; in the journal afterwards you can choose words for feelings (about 30 to pick from, none of them “wrong”). Whether naming a place in the body does the same as naming a feeling, the study does not say.

What this looks like in Anker

SOS is the round button at the bottom right, next to the bar. The first page carries the prompt to change your situation and a button, “Situation changed”. Below it is a link to the emergency plan, in case you only want to read the plan. Then come five steps, of which only two are required. You can also find an overview on the SOS page. Here is what each step is for.

  1. Rate the craving. A slider from 1 to 10. The step needs hardly any thinking, and the number is saved so that you can later compare it with the value from afterwards. It is required.
  2. Notice your body. “Where do you feel something right now?” Ten options, from “Head” via “Stomach” and “Hands” to “Whole body” and “Hard to say”. All of it is optional. The step moves your attention from the thought carousel to something immediate.
  3. Pause briefly. One fixed question (“What led me into this moment?”) and one that changes, for example “Are you running away from something painful right now?” The questions are invitations to look, not interrogations, and you can skip both.
  4. Choose a tool. “Which tool helps you now?” You get three suggestions from your favourites and can browse the whole library, type something of your own, or choose “I don’t know right now”.
  5. Commit to an action. “What will you do now?” Besides the craving, this is the only answer needed at the end. It is the real purpose of the flow: turning the urge into one concrete next step. If you chose a tool, Anker shows its instructions (“How to do it”) here. With “This is what I’ll do now” you confirm the step.

At the end, this page appears:

Good that you were here. An urge is not a decision.

Below it, the page adds that you have just taken some space for yourself and that this counts. The ending judges nothing. It only notes that you took some time, however the evening goes on.

After about 20 minutes Anker asks on Today how strong the craving is now. The question waits there until you next look in. It lapses at 3 am, so that the two craving readings still belong to the same moment.

Your emergency plan consists of eight short steps. It is short because it is read in the middle of craving. If you have read it once in advance, you do not have to look up in the crisis what it says.

What you choose in step four comes from the tools: a library of short exercises, from “Change the situation” via “Contact a friend” to “Say no”, including a breathing exercise. Every tool has short instructions (“How to do it”) that you can open up in the list. Some tools are marked as favourites in advance; you can change that and add your own. They are suggestions, not therapy. You find out for yourself what works, and it may change over time.

What SOS cannot do

SOS is not an emergency call and not crisis support. Anker is not monitored around the clock, and nobody is notified when you use SOS. There are moments when a person can help more than any app: someone you trust, a counselling service, a doctor. Under Me you find recovery contacts that you enter yourself, and an overview of help and crisis services. If you feel that you or others are in danger, the emergency number is the right way to go.

I am affected myself. That is why I cannot promise you anything, only describe how the flow is meant to work. It can happen that the craving does not ease, that a tool does not catch, or that you end up doing something you did not want to do. A difficult moment is not a failure. It is a reason to look at what came before, and that is what the journal is for. How to make sense of such moments is covered in the article on relapse prevention. And if you would like to set your limits in calmer times, the piece on bottom lines has some suggestions.

A first step for today

Today, add three things to Anker that you would do in the first minutes of a strong urge: as tools of your own under Me → Tools. Mark them with the star, and SOS will suggest them first, so you do not have to invent anything in the moment. Good actions are those that need no decision, involve the body and take you away from the trigger. They should be so small that you can manage them even with your heart pounding.

That is enough for today.

The next time the urge comes, it will probably be loud again. But you will have something in your hand that you decided beforehand, in peace. Between urge and action there will then be at least a small space, and you can use it.

Sources and further reading

  • Marlatt, G. A. & Gordon, J. R. (1985). Relapse Prevention: Maintenance Strategies in the Treatment of Addictive Behaviors. New York: Guilford Press.
  • Bowen, S. & Marlatt, G. A. (2009). Surfing the urge: Brief mindfulness-based intervention for college student smokers. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 23(4), 666–671.
  • Lieberman, M. D., Eisenberger, N. I., Crockett, M. J., Tom, S. M., Pfeifer, J. H. & Way, B. M. (2007). Putting feelings into words: Affect labeling disrupts amygdala activity in response to affective stimuli. Psychological Science, 18(5), 421–428.

The sources explain the ideas behind the article. Anker is not a clinically tested treatment and does not cite these studies as proof of effectiveness.

This feature in AnkerSOS

Keep reading

Start small. One check-in is enough.

Anker is free and runs in your browser and as a web app. There are no ads, no third-party tracking and no pressure.

If Anker has helped you and you would like to, you can voluntarily support its running and further development. Support Anker