Maybe you know this. In the morning everything is clear: not today, and not tomorrow either. By evening you are sitting on the sofa, tired, the day has been long, and a quiet voice begins to do sums. Just this once. Today was really a lot. I’ll start properly tomorrow. You notice that you are negotiating, and you know you are having a negotiation you did not want to have a few hours ago.
You may have resolved to do “less” or to “be more careful”. Resolutions like that sound sensible, yet in the moment they can be read almost any way you like. This article explains why a clear, personal limit that you draw in a calm moment can give you more to hold on to than a good intention. It shows what Anker offers for this, and it says honestly where the idea runs out.
Why we negotiate in the moment
Craving rarely arrives with a sign. It comes as tiredness, as anger, as boredom or as a suddenly very reasonable idea. At that point someone is weighing things up who wants something right now: relief, a pause, a different feeling. That someone is you, and you are not stupid. It is just that the sum being done is lopsided. The advantages lie in the next few minutes, the disadvantages later and somewhere vague.
A vague resolution has little to set against that. “I want to do less” has no edge. What does less mean: one round, two, a certain period, only on certain days? As long as that stays open, it can be decided again every time, and every new decision is another negotiation. Negotiating is tiring, especially when you are exhausted.
A limit you draw beforehand moves the decision somewhere else. You settle where the line runs while you are rested, thinking clearly and wanting nothing urgently. In the moment itself you then have less to weigh up. You only recognise it: this is the spot I looked at earlier.
What a bottom line is
A bottom line is a behaviour you deliberately want to avoid, described in your own words. It does not come from outside, and it is not a big goal such as “live healthily”. It is an edge where you say: up to here and no further. How narrow or wide you draw it is up to you. Some people word it very concretely, for instance as a particular action after a particular time or in a particular place, others more broadly. Whether the pattern involves alcohol, nicotine, gambling, media or something else makes no difference to the idea.
The term is known mainly from self-help groups, in particular from the world of twelve-step fellowships. I cannot tell you exactly how it is understood there, and that may differ from group to group. Anker uses the word in a plain sense: it is your personal limit. In the app, the line at that spot reads “You decide what goes here.” Bottom lines can be changed or deleted at any time, so they are allowed to grow with you. You create the first one right at the start, during onboarding.
When you word one, it helps to describe a behaviour rather than a trait. “No more playing after 10 pm” can be recognised in the moment; “becoming more disciplined” cannot. A limit marks a spot in your day and says nothing about what kind of person you are.
Green, yellow, red: why the middle matters
The bottom line is only one of three colours in Anker. Under Me you find the traffic light system. Red is for your bottom lines. Yellow is for your risk situations, that is, circumstances in which things get harder for you, such as being alone at home, after an argument, or awake late at night. Green is everything that gives you stability: people, activities, places, times of day. The app calls the whole thing your personal early-warning system: at a glance, what steadies you, what is risky for you and where your own limits are.
If you only know red, you know the edge but not the road that leads to it. Yellow buys you time. In the relapse-prevention literature, for example in the overview by Larimer, Palmer and Marlatt, risk situations are described as central: circumstances in which a slip becomes more likely, above all when no suitable coping response is to hand. If you write such situations down beforehand, in your own words, you still have room to move once you recognise one of them. There is more on this in the article on relapse prevention.
Green is the part that is easiest to forget. If you only occupy yourself with what you want to avoid, you end up with a list of prohibitions. Green reminds you of what already holds you up: a walk, a particular phone call, Sunday morning. In Anker, Today shows you up to three of your green situations each day, changing over time, under “This could give you support today”. That keeps what steadies you in view, even on days when nothing special is happening.
If-then: a plan for the calm moment
Knowing a limit is one thing; acting on it at the right moment is another. Here an idea from motivation research can help. In 1999 Peter Gollwitzer described what he calls implementation intentions: simple plans in the form “If situation X occurs, then I will do Y.” His overview is about pursuing goals in general, not about addictive patterns in particular. It describes how plans like these can help a person actually carry out an intention, because the situation itself becomes the cue for the action instead of you having to decide anew on the spot. Whether that holds for you can only be found out by trying.
For a bottom line it could look like this:
If I am alone in the evening and reach for my phone, then I stand up, step outside for a moment and afterwards send someone a message.
That is an example, not something you have to adopt. What matters is that the situation and the action are concrete enough to be recognised in the moment.
That is exactly what the eight-question plan is for. You can work one out in Anker for each bottom line. It starts with the bottom line itself and then goes through what comes before, which situations, thoughts, feelings and body signals belong to it, what you need then, what a different action could be and what should happen if you notice that you are already searching. Only the first question is required. You can add everything else later, and one more answer is enough to begin with. Up to three of your bottom lines also appear on Today, a different selection in a different order each day, so that you meet them in ordinary life and not only in a difficult moment.
When a line is crossed
At some point you may cross one of your lines. Many resolutions have no plan for this, and it is exactly then that it matters how you read the event. In their 1985 book, Marlatt and Gordon describe a phenomenon for this, the abstinence violation effect. It is a model, not a law of nature. It says that after a slip some people react in an all-or-nothing way. Thoughts such as “it doesn’t matter now anyway” and harsh self-reproach can contribute to a single event turning into more. According to the model, a lot depends on whether a slip is read as proof of one’s own inadequacy or as information about a situation one would like to understand better.
That is why Anker treats a crossed line as an event you can understand, not as a verdict. In the traffic-light system there is a question for it: “Has something happened?” with the button “Note it in the addiction journal”. It opens the journal, and the question “Did I cross a bottom line?” is already in the right place. You choose which one, and you write as much or as little as you like. Only the situation and the craving are needed for an entry; everything else is optional: your feelings, the trigger, what you would have needed. If you want, you save the situation as a risk situation, and it then appears among your yellow situations. The entry tells you that a difficult moment is not a failure, and your milestones stay as they are. They count what you have done, and they are never lost.
None of this excuses anything or glosses anything over. It means you can learn from what happened without everything before it being written off. Why shame rarely helps here is the subject of the article on shame.
What a bottom line cannot do
Anker does not judge which limits are right. The app does not know which pattern you have or what is appropriate for you, and it does not want to prescribe it. For some patterns, giving something up completely is the obvious line; for others it is a certain amount, a time of day or a place. What suits you is a very personal question, and you do not have to answer it alone. A counselling service, a therapist or a self-help group can help you find a limit that is realistic. Anker is not therapy and does not replace counselling.
I am affected myself, and Anker grew out of many notes of my own. It helped me a great deal in my recovery. Whether it helps you, I do not know. The idea behind this article is deliberately small: you write down where the edge is for you while you are calm.
A first step for today
You need five minutes. In Anker, open the traffic-light system under Me:
- Under “Red”, create a bottom line, in your own words and concrete enough that in the moment itself you could tell whether you are crossing it.
- Under “Yellow”, add a risk situation, a circumstance in which things get harder for you, and put an if-then line in the plan for your bottom line: “If …, then …”.
That is all you need today. You can add a green situation tomorrow under “Green”. A limit drawn in a calm hour does not take the negotiation away from the moment. It does give you something to refer back to while it is going on.
Sources and further reading
- Gollwitzer, P. M. (1999). Implementation intentions: Strong effects of simple plans. American Psychologist, 54(7), 493–503.
- Marlatt, G. A. & Gordon, J. R. (1985). Relapse Prevention: Maintenance Strategies in the Treatment of Addictive Behaviors. New York: Guilford Press.
- Larimer, M. E., Palmer, R. S. & Marlatt, G. A. (1999). Relapse prevention: An overview of Marlatt's cognitive-behavioral model. Alcohol Research & Health, 23(2), 151–160.
The sources explain the ideas behind the article. Anker is not a clinically tested treatment and does not cite these studies as proof of effectiveness.