Skip to content

Maybe you know the moment afterwards. Something happened that you did not want: a line you had set for yourself has been crossed. Your head goes quiet, and then a voice starts up. It says things like “That’s just who you are” or “Other people manage this.” It sounds very sure of itself, and it has advice: tell nobody, don’t look too closely, act as if nothing happened.

That advice feels like protection. It is the language of shame. This article looks at what shame does after a difficult moment, why it makes a poor guide, and what another inner stance can look like: one that takes what happened seriously without condemning you for it. The research literature calls it self-compassion.

What shame does to you after a difficult moment

Shame is an ordinary feeling. It usually turns up where something matters to us, and in that sense it is no defect. The trouble lies in where it points. It does not point at what happened but at you. “That was a difficult moment” becomes “Something is wrong with me.” And when you feel wrong as a whole person, the obvious impulse is to disappear.

Disappearing takes many forms. You stop opening your journal. You leave a friend’s message unanswered. You skip the meeting, or you tell your counsellor that things are going fine. Each of these steps is understandable. Taken together, they remove exactly what would help in the next hard moment: people who know, notes you could learn from, and a calm look at what actually happened. What you hide, you cannot look at. And what you do not look at often stays a pattern that repeats.

Then there is the inner voice that punishes. Many people consider it necessary: “If I am not hard on myself, I will get careless.” There is something true behind that, namely that your change matters to you. But harshness rarely does what it is meant to do. The moment afterwards often becomes harder to bear, and for many people a hard-to-bear state is exactly the one they want to get out of quickly, with something that brings brief relief. So the punishment can add to the pressure it was supposed to prevent. Many people describe it this way; it is an observation, not a law of nature.

Shame and guilt are two different things

In their book Shame and Guilt, Tangney and Dearing distinguish two feelings that are often mixed up in everyday speech. With shame, the negative judgement is aimed at the whole person: “I am bad, I am a mistake.” With guilt, it is aimed at a behaviour: “What I did does not fit what I want.” They also note that the two tend to bring different impulses. Shame is more closely linked with the wish to hide or withdraw. Guilt is more closely linked with the wish to put things right, for instance by apologising or doing something differently next time. These are tendencies that vary from person to person and situation to situation, not rules.

In everyday recovery this difference is quite practical. You can step back a little from a behaviour: you can look at it, understand it and change it. You cannot step back from yourself. If the sentence is “I am the problem”, there is no next step except hiding. If it is “This happened, and I would like to understand how it came about”, there is one. Neither feeling is wrong, and nobody has to switch them off. It only helps to notice which language is speaking in you at the moment.

All or nothing: why a slip can loom larger

The relapse-prevention model of Marlatt and Gordon describes high-risk situations, ways of coping with them, and confidence in being able to cope. It also describes what can go on inside a person after a slip, the so-called abstinence violation effect. What is meant is an all-or-nothing reaction: “Now it’s all pointless anyway.” The model describes how such thoughts, together with strong self-blame, can raise the risk that a single slip turns into more. That is why the model separates a single slip from relapse as a longer process, and suggests that the reaction to the first moment plays a part.

You do not have to take this as doctrine. But it fits what shame does, because shame passes a verdict on the whole. “I did it again, so this is who I am, so I might as well carry on.” The conclusion sounds logical and is still a leap: from one moment to the whole person, and from there to the whole future. A difficult moment tells you something about what was going on. It tells you less about who you are than the voice claims.

Self-compassion: a stance that takes things seriously

Neff describes self-compassion in three parts. The first is self-kindness: meeting yourself the way you would meet someone who matters to you, instead of condemning yourself. The second is a sense of common humanity: difficulty is part of being human, and you are not the only person in the world who struggles. The third is mindfulness: noticing painful feelings without pushing them away and without being swept along by them. Each of these has a counterpart that shame likes to produce: self-judgement, isolation and being swallowed whole by the feeling.

The most common worry is: won’t I get off too lightly? It is a reasonable worry, and one sentence will not settle it. Breines and Chen ran experiments in which people were reminded of a personal weakness or mistake. Those who took a self-compassionate view of it were afterwards more motivated to improve than comparison groups. These are laboratory experiments on a general question, not a study of addictive patterns, and whether this carries over to your daily life I cannot tell you. It does fit an experience many people share: we take more from someone who speaks to us kindly and clearly than from someone who tears us down.

So self-compassion does not mean glossing things over. It means looking, including at what you want to change, and choosing a tone in which you can actually listen.

Instead of “What is wrong with me?”, the question “What happened, and what do I need now?”

What this looks like in Anker

I built Anker so that shame gets as little to feed on as possible. The app uses no language of failure. When you record in a journal entry that you crossed a bottom line, it says: “A difficult moment is not a failure.” A crossed line is saved as an event. Milestones count what you have done and are never lost. Anker nags about nothing and keeps no list of missed routines. How to word a bottom line so that crossing it is information and not a verdict is covered in the article on bottom lines.

For the stance itself there is the self-compassion break under Routines. It takes about four minutes and has four steps:

  1. “What is hard right now?” You name it without judging it.
  2. “You are not alone.” A short text to read along: difficult moments are part of being human.
  3. “What would I say to a good friend?” You write down what you would say to someone going through the same thing.
  4. “What would be good for me now?” One small, kind step for yourself.

Whatever you write lands in the journal as a routine entry. You can switch steps off, reorder them or add your own. A guide with examples is in the article The self-compassion break. The Inner child routine is a little longer, about ten minutes and guided: you picture yourself as a child, ask what that child needs, and write a sentence the way a caring adult would say it. Some people find this helpful and others find it strange, and both are fine. The text says plainly that you can stop at any time, and that if something very stressful comes up you should turn to someone you trust or to a professional.

For the moment itself there is the tool “Self-compassion / positive self-talk”, with the note: “Talk to yourself kindly inside, as you would to a good friend.” You find it in the tool library and can pick it in SOS. In the journal, “Shame” is one of the triggers you can name. And in the traffic-light system, “Has something happened?” with the button “Note it in the addiction journal” leads to an entry with the question about the crossed bottom line already waiting, without blame.

Because shame keeps people from telling anyone, “Me” also holds your recovery contacts, with call and text buttons. Anker never calls anyone itself and shares your contacts with nobody. The button is just a reminder that you do not have to carry this alone. Whether any of this changes how you feel, I do not know, and Anker does not promise it.

What this cannot do

Practising self-compassion is not therapy. A routine and a few sentences do not replace a conversation with a professional, and Anker is not treatment. Shame can be very heavy, sometimes it is tied to old experiences, and it can be hard to shift alone. Then professional support, for example in an addiction counselling service or in psychotherapy, is worth having, and it is not a sign that you cannot manage by yourself.

A first step for today

The next time the punishing voice starts, pause for a moment. Say to yourself what you would say to a friend who had just been through exactly this. It is probably shorter and softer than what the voice is telling you. Then write down one single sentence in the journal. It does not need to be a good sentence or contain a solution.

That is all this step asks. If you like, tell someone you trust later on. Shame likes to stay hidden. A sentence that you write down or say aloud takes a small piece of it out.

Sources and further reading

  • Tangney, J. P. & Dearing, R. L. (2002). Shame and Guilt. New York: Guilford Press.
  • Marlatt, G. A. & Gordon, J. R. (1985). Relapse Prevention: Maintenance Strategies in the Treatment of Addictive Behaviors. New York: Guilford Press.
  • Neff, K. D. (2003). Self-compassion: An alternative conceptualization of a healthy attitude toward oneself. Self and Identity, 2(2), 85–101.
  • Breines, J. G. & Chen, S. (2012). Self-compassion increases self-improvement motivation. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 38(9), 1133–1143.

The sources explain the ideas behind the article. Anker is not a clinically tested treatment and does not cite these studies as proof of effectiveness.

This feature in AnkerRoutines

Keep reading

Start small. One check-in is enough.

Anker is free and runs in your browser and as a web app. There are no ads, no third-party tracking and no pressure.

If Anker has helped you and you would like to, you can voluntarily support its running and further development. Support Anker